Length: Perfect

Width: Slightly Wide

This size is too roomy overall and pinches my big toe.

Cordovan

Length: Perfect

Width: Moderately Narrow

I have a low volume foot and narrow heel with wide-ish toes. This shoe is too narrow at the big toe, though it fits perfectly over the top of the foot with just a little bit of space left for lace closure. I can only wear it with thin socks. 10D is much too small. A larger width (10.5D) is too roomy in the instep, as is the 11D. I aim to try 11B and 11.5B in the future.

Brown CXL (11B) Brown Cordovan (11B) Brown waxed flesh (10.5D)

Length: Perfect

Width: Perfect

I have twenty+ other reviews on Grailed and the Higgins Mill in 11B is probably my best-fitting boot. Nice and snug, low volume, tight heel, roomy at the toes. Just perfection. Can feel too tight if worn with thicker socks, but it's great with dress socks. The instep can feel a little too tight on a hot day. Other downside is that they don't breathe well at all. If the boot had an all-leather insole instead of a foam+leather one it would feel more supportive and breathable. The heel stiffener feels a bit too rigid and arch support is mediocre. Not worth the MSRP but great on sale. Also, 10.5D is a decent fit for slightly thicker socks, I just prefer the 11B.

Excellent style and quality of leather. Slightly chiseled toe box makes for a unique profile for Allen Edmonds.

Length: Slightly Long

Width: Slightly Wide

10.5D is roomy. 10E is far too roomy. Fantastic shoe, wish they would bring it back. I would like to find a pair in 10D or 11B.

Black smooth (10D) Crazy horse (10.5D)

Length: Slightly Short

Width: Perfect

10D fits well everywhere but crunches toes together. 10.5D fits perfect with a full-length insert. Boots have shrunken slightly over time and hard wear. The footbed of these Chippewas is fiberboard and does not wear well.

Length: Slightly Long

Width: Moderately Wide

Initially did not like these, but after break-in they have gotten better, especially after adding in a full-length insole to take up volume.

Brown Chromexcel (10D) Natural Waxed Commander (10E) Black Chromexcel Wedge (10.5D)

Length: Perfect

Width: Perfect

Excellent fit, one of my best overall. Fits quite snug, even after break-in. I cannot wear thick socks comfortably. Can become a little restrictive at the end of the day, and ultimately a larger size or width may end up being better. The 10D actually gives me a lot of heel rub when walking so they may be a tad short for my 10.5D-11C Brannock size. The shape of this last works well for natural toe-splay and I highly recommend it. 10E is an excellent fit overall with thick socks, very roomy but holds my foot perfectly well. 10.5D seems to be a perfect fit out of the box, if a bit roomy, but still working to break them in. The wedge sole may make them feel a little longer versus the commando lug sole, based on the point of toe-off.

Length: Perfect

Width: Perfect

Fits very well, but slightly roomy over the instep and snug in the toes.

Length: Slightly Long

Width: Slightly Narrow

Too roomy in heel/ankle and too narrow in the toes.

Brown veg-tan w/micro stud rubber sole

Length: Slightly Short

Width: Perfect

The Diesel is absolutely one of my favorite boots. I just wish it fit. I have a low volume foot with a narrow heel & ankle and wide toes. The only way for me to get a good fit in the Diesel is to go TTS and wear super-thick socks or use a 3/4 length arch insert. This is not very comfortable as it raises the heel, putting more pressure on the forefoot. A full-length insert can work as long as it is thin and does not squish the toes too much. I finally gave up on this last and have moved onto the Brass Boot as my preferred Grant Stone footwear (more on that later). In the Leo last I have tried the following sizes: 9.5D, 9.5E, 10D, 10E, 10.5D, 11D. 10E is my best-fitting Leo size without relying on inserts. The length feels right, the volume is a little bit much but perfect with medium/thick socks. The quarters completely close around the top but that is a feature I have had to get accustomed to with my skinny runner's ankles. The only thing wrong with it is the taper of the toes, especially the big toe. I get too much pressure on the side of the big toe and it's nigh unwearable. Thankfully, the Floyd last from Grant Stone totally fixes the toe room issue and I highly recommend it!

Length: Perfect

Width: Perfect

While the fit is excellent, I find the overall volume of the 10E to be a bit too much. Next time I would go with a 10.5D.

Ivory Suede, Leather Sole

Length: Perfect

Width: Slightly Narrow

A little bit narrow in the toes with too much volume over the instep. Not my best fitting shoe, but works well with a 3/4 arch insert like Pedag's.

Storm Kudu Crepe sole

Length: Very Long

Width: Slightly Wide

10.5D feels a little too long but also too narrow in the toes while being loose in the heel. The heel and ankle lockdown was not near enough to be comfortable walking in. I usually can't wear chukkas anyway because of my low instep and narrow heel, but I really wish these worked for me. The Storm Kudu is phenomenal, rich, supple, and with a fantastic grain character.

Brown calf

Length: Perfect

Width: Moderately Wide

Great shoe for the price! Fit was not to my liking, however. Much too roomy/voluminous. With a thin insert, it fit fine.

Length: Slightly Short

Width: Moderately Narrow

Could not make this size work for me. Arch length felt a little too short, and toebox too narrow, while the overall volume was too much. Incredible boot otherwise.

Natural Chromexcel

Length: Perfect

Width: Perfect

Definitely true-to-size and a low-volume last. Almost runs a little bit short, but fit is perfectly snug with thin or medium socks. I just wish their quality control was above horrendous levels. Customer service was A+, however.

Natural CXL Roughout (10.5D) Natural CXL (10D)

Length: Perfect

Width: Moderately Wide

I really wanted to like the Elston last. It's excellent, anatomically speaking, because it has a narrow heel and wide forefoot. This spelled disaster for my low volume D-width foot though. The 10D would have been absolute perfection if the toe taper was less drastic - the boot put a lot of pressure on the outside of the big toe even after the break-in process. Toe stiffeners don't typically seem to stretch. The 10.5D fit well in the heel but was absolutely too sloppy through the midfoot and forefoot. I am sure after break-in that the sloppiness would have lessened, but I did not want to risk it and returned my pair.

Waxed flesh

Length: Slightly Short

Width: Perfect

Awesome boot, but sadly too narrow in the toe box for me. Going a half size up would be far too roomy (10.5D is already sloppy in the midfoot and heel).

Light brown suede

Length: Perfect

Width: Moderately Wide

Runs bigger than I expected. Quality is decent for the price (nice suede), but the foam insole blew out in no time, leaving very little shock absorption. Also, the heel block is very heavy and throws the balance off. I added a third set of eyelets above the existing ones to compensate for the abysmal heel lockdown.

Cinnamon Waxed Flesh

Length: Slightly Long

Width: Moderately Narrow

This last runs very long, and narrow. However, the heel is massive. Not a good fit. CS recommended a smaller size - I would try 9.5EE if I went for it again. But ended up getting rid of both pairs. Highly recommend this boot if you can make it work. Opt for the commando lug as it is nicer than Dainite on the MP.

Length: Slightly Long

Width: Moderately Narrow

This last runs very long, and narrow. However, the heel is massive. Not a good fit. CS recommended a smaller size - I would try 9.5EE if I went for it again. But ended up getting rid of both pairs.