What others wear in
the Allen Edmonds McAllister

• CodeSlow5

  Brannock size

  9.5 C

  L:

  Length:

  -

  Width:

  -

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  C

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  9.0 d

  Variant

  Leather sole

  Purchase Date

  10/20

  Review

  Fit is great, comfort is exceptional. I was able to wear these shoes all night at my wedding reception and they were great both standing and dancing in.

• North After It All

  Brannock size

  11.5 EE

  L:

  Length:

  11.5

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  11

  R:

  Length:

  11

  Width:

  EE

  Arch:

  10.5

  Wears this style in

  12.0 eee

  Variant

  Dark chili w/ Dainite soles

  Purchase Date

  12/12/2022

  Review

  Fits well in width. Facings spread a little due to high instep. Heel to ball is long, but wearable.

  • 

    

• still-unit-8402

  Brannock size

  10 D

  L:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  10

  R:

  Length:

  9

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  9

  Wears this style in

  9.0 d

  Variant

  A little tight, great shoe

  Purchase Date

  19994

• gv7

  Brannock size

  12 C

  L:

  Length:

  12

  Width:

  C

  Arch:

  12

  R:

  Length:

  12

  Width:

  C

  Arch:

  12

  Wears this style in

  11.5 d

• lucky-fire-9174

  Brannock size

  10.5 EE

  L:

  Length:

  10.5

  Width:

  EE

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  10.5

  Width:

  EE

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  10.5 e

  Variant

  Black leather sole

  Purchase Date

  11/21

• GaitPosts

  Brannock size

  10 C

  L:

  Length:

  10

  Width:

  C

  Arch:

  10

  R:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  C

  Arch:

  9.5

  Wears this style in

  9.5 c

  Variant

  Walnut calf, leather sole

  Purchase Date

  06/17

  Review

  Pretty good fit. The right shoe has just a bit of extra room in it—more than other Allen Edmonds shoes I have on the same last, but not enough that my foot feels like it’s sliding around inside the shoe all day.

• weathered-art-1269

  Brannock size

  9.5 E

  L:

  Length:

  9

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  9.5

  R:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  9.5

  Wears this style in

  8.5 e

• noisy-frog-7538

  Brannock size

  8.5 E

  L:

  Length:

  8

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  8.5

  R:

  Length:

  8

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  8.5

  Wears this style in

  8.5 d

• aged-mountain-5392

  Brannock size

  9.5 D

  L:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  10.0 d

• jacktheenthusiast

  Brannock size

  10

  L:

  Length:

  10

  Width:

  -

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  10

  Width:

  -

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  9.5 e

  Variant

  McCallister in burgandy weave.

  Review

  More of a casual shoe than dress. This fits with the other classic 65 last designs of AE. It wears well as a casual shoe. I like the dainite sole with this shoe. Even going up a width it feels a bit narrow but after time it broken quite well.

• old-hill-4263

  Brannock size

  9.5 E

  L:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  9.5 d

  Purchase Date

  11/13

  Review

  Very comfortable, worn for formal occasions

• quiet-tree-5961

  Brannock size

  9.5 D

  L:

  Length:

  9.5

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  9

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  8.0 d

  Purchase Date

  0118

  Review

  I bought this used. Allen Edmonds fits me perfectly. Dainite soles.

• lucky-silence-9757

  Brannock size

  9 D

  L:

  Length:

  9

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  9

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  9.0 d

  Variant

  calf, bourbon, leather sole

  Review

  9D too long

• calm-sunset-2316

  Brannock size

  13.5 EEE

  L:

  Length:

  13.5

  Width:

  EEE

  Arch:

  13.5

  R:

  Length:

  13.5

  Width:

  EEE

  Arch:

  13.5

  Wears this style in

  13.0 eee

• rapid-glade-4116

  Brannock size

  7.5 E

  L:

  Length:

  7.5

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  7.5

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  7.0 e

  Variant

  Dark chili

  Purchase Date

  04/22

• classic.jase

  Brannock size

  13 D

  L:

  Length:

  13

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  13

  R:

  Length:

  13

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  13

  Wears this style in

  13.0 e

  Variant

  Dark Chili

  Review

  I have a low instep, measure slightly over a 13, between a D and E. D was too narrow in the 65 last, which is a long, narrow last. E fits perfectly.

  • 

    
  • 

    
  • 

    

• blue-snowflake-4498

  Brannock size

  12 D

  L:

  Length:

  12

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  7.5

  R:

  Length:

  12

  Width:

  D

  Arch:

  7.5

  Wears this style in

  12.0 d

  Variant

  I don't own McAllister but the McTavish that I think it uses the same last.

  Purchase Date

  05/21

  Review

  The McTavish are the most comfortable dress shoes I've ever owned. They feel like tennis shoes, really. I can wear them all day.

  • 

    

• Cor10

  Brannock size

  10.5 B

  L:

  Length:

  10.5

  Width:

  B

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  10.5

  Width:

  B

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  10.5 d

• royal-moon-9783

  Brannock size

  10 E

  L:

  Length:

  10

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  -

  R:

  Length:

  10

  Width:

  E

  Arch:

  -

  Wears this style in

  10.0 e